Commentary: Active investing v.2.0


Commentary: Active investing v.2.0 by Gabriel Karageorgiou and George Serafeim - November 28, 2017 12:00 pm



Nobel laureate Bob Dylan's lyrics from his 1964 release "The Times They Are a-Changin' " are words every business leader should keep in mind when planning for the future: "… the present now will later be past, the order is rapidly fadin' …"



We believe this is even truer for the active asset management industry.



Over the past years, various advancements radically changed the telecommunications, technology, aviation, medicine and auto industries, to name a few. Think of the disruption Tesla is causing to the auto industry, the revolution Apple brought to the phone market, and the rebellion Amazon.com introduced in retail. Previously established players had to adapt to compete in the new norm of things. Those who didn't, disappeared.



A wave of change is coming to the asset management industry, which at its core has not materially changed its practices, processes and approach over the past decades. Still, a portfolio manager is in control of vast amounts of assets, following investment approaches that utilize financial information that is now standardized, common and well understood by most market actors. It should not be surprising then that long-term alpha generation has become so much more difficult.



In the meantime, demand for passive strategies from asset owners and retail investors has increased substantially amid supply growth from asset managers. The growth in passive investing is justified. It came as a response to the industry becoming fat, lazy and self-serving. Standard & Poor's research finds most active managers tend to underperform their respective benchmarks over medium- and long-term horizons. At the same time, way too many products charge high management fees while quasi-indexing and seeking to minimize tracking error. According to a Harvard University study, for every dollar managed by truly actively managed funds, there are $3 in index and quasi-index funds. And the majority of asset managers are compensated as bureaucrats: a flat management fee with no performance fees in place. Interestingly, on this last front, Abigail Johnson of Fidelity Investments recently slapped the industry in the face by admitting the lack of alignment with customers by announcing the introduction of fulcrum fees.



Does that mean active management is fading out? Yes, in the form we know it today. No, for managers who will develop capabilities enabling them to understand unstructured data and take better informed decisions.



How can managers differentiate themselves and ensure they are on the winning side of the equation? There are three forces we see acting as catalysts



1. Integration of ESG data



Many managers are still of the impression that integrating environmental, social and governance factors into their capital allocation process is purely associated with making their portfolios "greener" or more ethical. To us it is shocking that the overwhelming number of investors still make investment choices disregarding data around employee turnover and engagement, customer policies around product safety, environmental productivity as captured in energy, water and waste intensity of operations, and the governance and incentive structure that defines the culture of the organization. As with everything, the way a term is defined will determine how the term will be perceived. A sustainable company, from an investor's standpoint, is one that is managed in such a way that it is positioned for long-term success; a company whose management possesses the quality to understand and address short-term risks, and the drive to innovate to capture long-term opportunities. ESG data are the means that can enable an investor to understand a company's strategy, corporate purpose and management quality, at scale and in an unbiased, quantifiable way. Research suggests companies managed for the long run, exhibit better financial returns. As intangible assets increasingly dominate companies' balance sheets, and strategy becomes part of a company's valuation, ESG analysis will move financial analysis to business analysis.



2. Utilization of technological advancements



The term "quant investing" is often perceived as intraday algorithmic trading where sophisticated systems try to identify arbitrage opportunities down to milliseconds. We define quantitative investing as an investment process that follows a rules-based, structured and consistent approach, which analyzes vast amount of data with the objective to take better informed decisions by uncovering hidden insights.



We as human beings have feelings and emotions. We evaluate gains differently than we evaluate losses using certain heuristics. Gains satisfy us less than (equal) losses hurt us. We have convictions and beliefs that lead to biases. And the more often we had been right in the past, the more difficult it is for us to realize the moment we are wrong. In addition, we have limited time during a day and limited capacity on the information we can assess.



A rules-based approach does not exhibit these human biases, does not build convictions based on intuition, is consistent in its assessments, can assess billions of data points and can explore different (known and unknown to us) structural combinations in short periods of time. It also provides an investor with transparency on the steps followed, the factors considered and the (consistent) reasoning an allocation was made. Technological advancements in realms such as big data and machine learning all have as an objective to improve our information environment and decision-making process, by addressing limitations we as human beings have. Active management in its traditional form will evolve to allow the integration of insights produced by such systems.



3. Transparency and representation of beneficiaries' preferences



In the long past, managers were facing only one question: "how much return"?



Later, the question "how much risk?" was added.



Now, the question "how was the return generated?" is being added.



This last question is meant purely in terms of alignment between an investor's personal beliefs and her/his investments. Imagine a pediatrician that finds her pension is invested in consumer good companies that offer primarily high-sugar child nutrition, or a doctor invested in tobacco companies.Similarly, a materials scientist would be pleased to be invested in companies with exposure to advanced additive manufacturing or a security officer in companies offering security services. In the era of information and transparency, investors have started developing that sense of connection with their investments (pension and direct allocations). Investors have views and they want them to be reflected in the way they allocate capital. Thus, they will set managers responsible to ensure proper integration of those views in the way their money is managed. A huge transfer of wealth is in sight over the next years. Millennials are due to inherit trillions of dollars. They tend to view the world differently from their predecessors and they want their investment decisions to serve a wider purpose to continue legacies and protect reputations.



Conclusion



ESG analysis will not replace financial analysis. Similarly, machine learning will not replace portfolio managers.



However, managers who leverage ESG data along with financial data and utilize technological advancements will replace those who don't, to define active investing v.2.0.



Gabriel Karageorgiou is a partner at Arabesque Asset Management, London, and George Serafeim is the Jakurski Family Associate Professor of Business Administration at Harvard Business School, Boston. This article represents the views of the authors. It was submitted and edited under Pensions & Investments guidelines, but is not a product of P&I's editorial team.


BIMB INVESTMENT LAUNCHES THE WORLD’S FIRST ESG SUKUK FUND
BIMB INVESTMENT LAUNCHES THE WORLD’S FIRST ESG SUKUK FUND  BIMB INVESTMENT IS THE FIRST IN THE WORLD TO INTRODUCE SUKUK UNIT TRUST FUND THAT INTEGRATES SHARIAH AN...
BIMB INVESTMENT WINS MALAYSIA’S BEST ISLAMIC ASSET AND FUND MANAGER 2018 AWARD
BIMB INVESTMENT WINS MALAYSIA’S BEST ISLAMIC ASSET AND FUND MANAGER 2018 AWARD SECOND CONSECUTIVE WIN FROM ALPHA SOUTHEAST ASIA  KUALA LUMPUR: BIMB Investment...
BIMB INVESTMENT LAUNCH MALAYSIA’S FIRST SHARIAH SUSTAINABLE AND RESPONSIBLE INVESTMENT (SRI) EQUITY FUND
BIMB INVESTMENT LAUNCH MALAYSIA’S FIRST SHARIAH SUSTAINABLE AND RESPONSIBLE INVESTMENT (SRI) EQUITY FUND  FIRST SHARIAH EQUITY FUND APPROVED UNDER SECURITIES COMM...
Market Spotlight, Thursday 24 May 2018
MARKET SPOTLIGHT, THURSDAY 24 MAY 2018       Click here for detail   ...
Zero-Rated GST: Positive for Consumers
ZERO-RATED GST: POSITIVE FOR CONSUMERS   GST is now zero-rated effective 1 June The government has announced that the Goods and Services Tax (GST) rate will be ...
Economic Viewpoint Trade Friction but Not Collapsing Demands
ECONOMIC VIEWPOINT TRADE FRICTION BUT NOT COLLAPSING DEMANDS Flirting with a trade war The trade tension between the US and China has escalated. On 7 April, the US Presi...
BIMB Investment Declares 8% Distribution Yield For BIMB-Arabesque i Global Dividend Fund 1
BIMB INVESTMENT DECLARES 8% DISTRIBUTION YIELD FOR BIMB-ARABESQUE i GLOBAL DIVIDEND FUND 1 Exceeding target benchmark of 6% for two consecutive years. KUALA LUMPUR, Frid...
BIMB-Arabesque Asia Pacific Shariah-ESG Equity Fund Launching
On 23 January 2018, BIMB Investment Management Berhad with its strategic partner, Arabesque Asset Management Holding Ltd, UK launched the BIMB-Arabesque Asia Pacific Shariah-ESG...
Data revolution shaping socially responsible investing
7 March 2018:   Data revolution shaping socially responsible investing. Investors who want to integrate environmental, social and governance (ESG) principles into...
Shariah Compliant Investing Version 2.0
9 Feb 2018:   Shariah Compliant Investing Version 2.0  In this article, Gabriel Karageorgiou, a partner at Arabesque Asset Management, takes a look at how th...
BIMB Invest Launches BIMB-Arabesque Asia Pacific Shariah-ESG Equity Fund, the First Asia Pacific Big Data & Fintech Fund in Malaysia
23 Jan 2018:   BIMB INVEST LAUNCHES BIMB-ARABESQUE ASIA PACIFIC SHARIAH-ESG EQUITY FUND, THE FIRST ASIA PACIFIC BIG DATA & FINTECH FUND IN MALAYSIA A NEW DIMENSIO...
Responsible Investing: Using AI to Tap Demand for Socially Responsible Investments
12 Jan 2018:   Responsible Investing: Using AI to tap demand for socially responsible investments Socially responsible investing (SRI) is becoming more mainstream...
Smart Investor - Meeting the Needs of Islamic Finance
Smart Investor - Meeting the Needs of Islamic Finance: BIMB-Arabesque i Global Dividend Fund 1  ...
Termination of Complimentary Group Personal Accident (GPA) Takaful Coverage
12 Dec 2017:   TERMINATION OF COMPLIMENTARY GROUP PERSONAL ACCIDENT (GPA) TAKAFUL COVERAGE Dear Valued Investors As we usher 2018, we would like to take a mom...
The New Frontier in Sustainable Investing
The New Frontier in Sustainable Investing Omar Selim founded Arabesque Asset Management to invest sustainably. He needed better data, so he built the most comprehensive data...
Commentary: Active investing v.2.0
Commentary: Active investing v.2.0 by Gabriel Karageorgiou and George Serafeim - November 28, 2017 12:00 pm Nobel laureate Bob Dylan's lyrics from his 1964 release "The ...
Bursa Shariah Investing Fair 2017
BIMB Holdings Berhad along with its subsidiaries, Bank Islam Malaysia Bhd, Syarikat Takaful Malaysia Bhd, BIMB Securities Sdn Bhd and BIMB Investment Management Berhad participa...
Economic Update: 3Q2017 GDP at 6.2% - Higher Than Expected
Economic Update: 3Q2017 GDP at 6.2% - Higher Than Expected   ...
MIA International Accountants Conference 2017
The MIA International Accountants Conference (MIA Conference) is an annual flagship event which provides the best avenue for insightful discussions for the accountancy professio...
BIMB INVESTMENT DECLARES 7.5% INCOME DISTRIBUTION YIELD
BIMB Investment declares 7.5% income distribution yield KUALA LUMPUR, Wednesday, 1 November 2017 – BIMB Investment Management Berhad (“BIMB Invest”), ...
Drop Us A Line
Your Name
Your IC or Passport
Your Email
Your Phone Number
Your Message